Why rekey between tenants?
Keys get copied without anyone thinking much about it. One goes to a cousin, a contractor cuts a spare, a ring disappears at the beach. Once the lease ends, all of those keys still open your door. A rekey changes the pins inside the lock, and that's what turns them into scrap.
There's a paperwork benefit too. If something goes wrong later, you can show the old keys stopped working before the new tenant arrived.
| What happened | Do old keys still work? | What fixes it |
|---|---|---|
| Tenant moved out, lock untouched | Yes, every copy | Rekey |
| Tenant lost a key mid-lease | Yes | Rekey |
| Tenant added their own lock | Not on the tenant's lock | Get the key, then decide |
| Lock is worn or sticks | Yes | Replace or repair |
What is the Turnover Key Count?
The Turnover Key Count is a habit we suggest to every landlord. For each door, write down how many keys exist before the rekey and how many exist after.
That's two lines per door. On the first line, note what the tenant handed back and what's missing. On the second, note how many keys were cut to the new pattern and who holds each one.
Take a house with a front door, a back door and a garage side door, all on one new key pattern. You'd log three locks and four keys cut, with two staying with you and two going to the new tenant. Keep the sheet in the property file. At the next turnover you begin with a real number, not a guess.
Rekey or replace?
A rekey changes the inside of the lock so a new key works and the old ones don't. A replacement puts a different lock on the door. Our lock rekey page has the full comparison, but in a rental the call mostly depends on how the hardware looks and feels.
| Situation | Better choice |
|---|---|
| Lock turns smoothly, no damage, finish is fine | Rekey |
| Several doors, you want one key for all of them | Rekey, same pattern |
| Lock sticks, spins or feels loose | Replace, or repair first |
| Tenant left the lock damaged | Replace |
| Hardware is very old or mismatched | Replace |
A rekey is also how you get every door at a property onto one key. Managing several units? Read our post on master keying for a rental property before you settle on a system.
What Delaware says about locks and entry
Three parts of Delaware's landlord-tenant code touch a turnover.
Tenants can add a lock. Under 25 Del. C. § 5509, a tenant may install a new lock at their own cost if they tell the landlord in writing, give the landlord a key, the lock fits the system already in place, and the installation doesn't damage the door. So when a tenant leaves, look at every door for a lock you didn't install. Found one? Get its key before you rekey around it.
You need notice to enter. The same section says a landlord gives the tenant at least 48 hours' notice before entering, between 8:00 a.m. and 9:00 p.m., except for repairs the tenant asked for and emergencies. That's why we'd book the rekey after the tenant has moved out and handed back the keys. Doing it mid-tenancy means the tenant has to agree or you have to meet the notice rule.
Deposits have a clock. Section 5514 says a landlord who isn't entitled to all of a security deposit has to return it within 20 days of the lease ending. A rekey is an ordinary turnover job, so slot it in with your walkthrough and don't let it drift.
None of this is legal advice. Your lease and your attorney have the final say.
A turnover checklist
Work through it in this order and the turnover stays quick.
- Collect every key from the outgoing tenant and count them.
- Walk each door and note any lock that isn't yours.
- Try each lock. Does the key turn without a fight, and does the bolt go all the way out?
- Choose per door whether to rekey, repair or replace.
- Book the locksmith between move-out and the new tenant's first day.
- Fill in the Turnover Key Count for every door.
- Give the new tenant the new keys only, and write down how many you handed over.
- Test every key in its own door before you leave.
People forget mailbox and shed locks all the time, so put them on the list. Our mailbox keys service handles the mailbox side.
What happens when we rekey your rental in Sussex County, DE?
We're a mobile locksmith out of Georgetown, so nobody has to drive to a shop. The van comes to the rental, wherever it sits in Kent and Sussex County. We rekey the cylinders right there, cut the new keys and try each one in its lock. Close to Georgetown? See our page on rekeying in Georgetown.
Before a tool touches a lock, we lay out the options and you pick. Often that's a rekey. Now and then a lock is too worn to bother with, and we'll say so and explain why.
Phones are answered Sunday through Thursday, 7:00am to 10:00pm, and Friday, 7:00am to 3:30pm. We're closed Saturday. The request form takes messages at any hour and we reply when we open.
When you call, tell us the town and the rental's address, how many doors there are and what locks are on them, and the dates the tenant leaves and the next one arrives. Mention it if the tenant added a lock of their own.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to rekey between tenants in Delaware?
How long does a rekey take?
Is rekeying better than changing the locks?
Can a tenant change the locks in Delaware?
Can I put every door on one key?
What if a tenant lost a key during the lease?
Do you rekey rentals outside Georgetown?
Who rekeys rental properties in Sussex County, DE?
Next steps
Count what you've got, walk the doors and choose a date that falls between move-out and move-in. After that, request service and tell us your town and the number of doors, or call (302) 271-0155.
About the author
The team at Lock and Key Locksmith wrote this. We're a locally owned, mobile locksmith in Georgetown, Delaware, working across 50 towns in Kent and Sussex County, with 15 years of experience. Phones are answered Sunday to Thursday, 7:00am to 10:00pm, and Friday, 7:00am to 3:30pm.
Turning over a rental? Call (302) 271-0155 and tell us your town and how many doors.

